Primary Image
Step-by-Step Guide to Roasting a Juicy, Flavorful Turkey
I roasted my turkey early this year (2025) on Saturday. I found a brining recipe I have been wanting to try, and I wanted to try and "smoke" it in my oven using Hickory Wood chips, with the turkey covered tightly with tin foil. I roasted it at 275º. After two hours, I realized the wood chips were more or less soaking up the juice of the turkey, so I pulled it out of the pan, removed the foil packet of wood chips I put them in (poking holes in the foil), and put the turkey back in the oven at 325º. I tested it with several digital thermometers, and a neighbor had given me his non-wireless thermometer, which had a wire from the turkey to a display on the counter. At 3 hours, it said it was done, but the legs were still as stiff as a board (we like it falling apart), and there was no way a 20 lb turkey could be done in 3 hours. I kept it in for another hour, still wrapped in foil, and it was perfect! I have never had a turkey that was so moist. When I sealed the turkey in packages, you could see the juices from the breast meat as the sealer vacuum-packed it. I will make the brine and put the liquid smoke rub on the turkey again. Our neighbor came over just as we were carving it, and he said it turned out really well. I think the low and slow is the best, too! If anyone wants the recipe, let me know!
Nancy S.
PS Oh yes... I also wash my turkey (call me old school), and I remove as much of that horrible globby fat as I can! When I debone it, I get as much meat off that turkey as anyone can get. So, come Thanksgiving, all I have to do is make the side dishes and make stuffing. I kept the turkey broth and will use it to make gravy. It is sitting in the freezer waiting.
Defrost your turkey? Why? Yes, I know every professional chef is always saying that is what to do with a frozen bird. Defrost it because it won't get done otherwise. My mom discovered by accident fifty years ago that you can cook a bird from frozen if you go low and slow. Takes longer but that's the method that has been used in our family ever since I've been alive. And it comes out juicier than a defrosted bird without the need to baste. I'll stick with the frozen bird, thank you.
How low oven temp
And how long?
I’ve found that brining the turkey before roasting makes for a moist, tender and flavorful turkey.
After years of "traditional roasting" of turkeys (and chickens), we switched to using an electric roaster. Yes, the skin may not brown and crisp up quite as much as it does in an oven, it frees up valuable oven space, never needs basting (if you have one with a self basting lid) and cooks much faster. Liquid in the bottom of the pan is a great start to great gravy when it's done. Chicken broth, Miller High Life (my favorite) or water will do.
We never stuff the turkey when we cook the bird in the electric roaster, and instead do that in the regular oven.
Always pleased with the results doing the turkey this way!
For many years I have relied on Reynolds turkey-size cooking bags. Much shorter cooking time and they have not failed to be moist and tender, though not crispy and browned as some want to display.
Do not use cooking bags if you have have parrots or other birds in the house. They can be deadly.
And then there are those of us who love Reynolds Oven Bags - Turkey Size. A 21+ lb bird in 2 3/4 hours. Breast down in the bag create juicy breast meat, but turning it over to carve I have not yet mastered.
Our answer to this is a central carving trolley so you have two people to hold the bird using oven gloves and turn together. We cook ours in double layers of tinfoil and turn it half way through cooking. Agree before hand which way to turn it though!! Juicy breast meat every time.
We grew up learning that turkey was to be cooked for at least 15 to 20 minutes (longer for much larger birds) at higher temp (400 to 425F) to bring it up out of the "danger zone" faster as well as "set" the skin (to prevent the skin from going soggy or soft as well as prevent skin splitting), then reduced the heat to cook lower (325 to 350 F) and slower to avoid overly dry meat. Altitude also matters!
- « Previous
- 1
- 2
- …
- 10
- Next »


Comments