How to Make Seed-Starting Mix (DIY Soilless Potting Mix Recipe)

If your seeds keep sprouting—and then suddenly dying—you’re not alone. One of the most common seed-starting mistakes is using garden soil straight from the backyard. While it may seem natural, garden soil is heavy, compacted, and often full of weed seeds and disease that can stop seedlings before they ever get going.

The secret to strong, healthy seedlings is a light, soilless seed-starting mix. It’s clean, airy, moisture-retentive, and designed specifically for germination. The good news? You don’t have to buy it. Making your own seed-starting mix is easy and affordable and gives your seeds the best possible start.

Seed-starting mix is a sterile, lightweight growing medium designed to help seeds germinate quickly without disease or compaction.

Seed-Starting Mix Recipe

Use the three ingredients below in the quantities shown to make a good all-around potting mix for starting seeds. All parts are measured by volume, so you can use anything you like to measure your ingredients. All ingredients are available at most nurseries and garden stores.

• 2 parts compost. You can use your own garden compost or buy some. Break up clumps with your hands or, ideally, screen the compost to achieve a fine texture. Screening (or “sieving”) compost involves running it through a screen made of hardware cloth to separate out any materials that haven’t broken down yet. The compost will slowly release nutrients into the mix to help feed your seedlings as they grow.
• 2 parts coir (coconut fiber) or leaf mold. If you’ve purchased a block of coir, soak it in water first until it’s fibrous and easily pulled apart. Alternatively, use well-rotted leaf mold. The coir or leaf mold adds bulk and helps to retain moisture.
• 1 part perlite. Perlite makes the mix lighter and helps stop it from becoming too wet. You can use sand if you prefer, but this will result in a heavier mixture.

Thoroughly mix all of the ingredients. After you make a batch, store it for later use in a lidded container or in old potting soil sacks (or any other strong plastic sack) with the top rolled down and secured. Keep it in a dry, cool place.

Using Your Seed-Starting Mix

Before you fill your pots, trays, and flats with seed-starting mix, be sure to clean them! After thoroughly washing with soap and water, rinse the containers in a solution of 1 part chlorine bleach to 9 parts water to kill remaining plant disease microorganisms that could weaken or kill your tender young seedlings. See how to clean pots and containers.

Moisten your seed-starting mix before you use it so it’s damp but not dripping. Fill your seed flats, plug trays, or pots with the mix, taking care to fill right into the corners. Gently tamp the soil down. Sow your seeds according to the packet instructions. 

Water carefully using a mister or a watering can fitted with a very fine rose. Alternatively, make your own watering bottle by piercing holes in the cap of a plastic bottle using a pin. This will provide a fine spray of water to gently water your delicate seeds.

Once the seedlings have germinated, water from below instead. Place containers in a shallow tray of water until the surface of the mix becomes moist, then remove.

Plants usually need potting on at least once before transplanting into their final location. When potting on, you can use the same potting mix or add worm compost or a balanced organic fertilizer for hungry plants such as tomatoes and cabbage family plants.

See our full article on how to start seeds indoors.

Container Potting Mix 

For growing plants in larger containers, mix two parts garden compost with one part coir or leaf mold. Add two or three handfuls of perlite per 10 gallons of the coir-compost mix to help improve drainage. Hungry plants will also appreciate a similar amount of worm compost, or mix in a slow-release organic fertilizer according to the manufacturer’s instructions.

For long-term container plants, include loam or good-quality garden soil in your potting mix. Combine one part loam (or screened garden soil) with one part garden compost, and add some slow-release organic fertilizer. This mix would be suitable for many containerized fruit trees, bushes, and perennial vegetables.

Seed Starting Mix vs. Potting Soil

Feature	Seed-Starting Mix	Potting Soil
Texture	Very fine and light	Coarser and heavier
Nutrient Level	Low (ideal for seeds)	Higher (better for established plants)
Drainage	Excellent	Good to moderate
Disease Risk	Low (sterile or pasteurized)	Moderate
Weed Seeds	None	Sometimes present
Best Use	Germinating seeds	Growing mature plants in containers
Root Development	Encourages delicate roots	Can overwhelm young roots

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use potting soil instead of seed-starting mix?

Potting soil is better than garden soil, but it’s still too coarse and nutrient-rich for germinating seeds. Seed-starting mix is finer and lighter, and it encourages delicate roots to develop properly.

Why shouldn’t I use garden soil for starting seeds?

Garden soil compacts easily, drains poorly, and may contain weed seeds, insects, or diseases that can kill young seedlings before they mature.

Does seed-starting mix need fertilizer?

No—seeds contain all the nutrients they need to germinate. Fertilizer should only be added after seedlings develop their first true leaves.

Can I reuse seed-starting mix?

It’s best not to reuse it for germination, as it may harbor disease. However, used mix can be added to garden beds or container plantings.

What is the best seed-starting mix for vegetables like tomatoes and peppers?

A fine-textured, well-draining soilless mix with compost, coir, and perlite works well for most vegetable seeds, including tomatoes and peppers.

Start planning your garden! Get a free trial of the Almanac Garden Planner here.